Many readers consider Stephen Chbosky’s coming of age novel The Perks of Being a Wallflower a modern classic. It’s easy to see why the focus on identity has helped it become required reading for numerous high school classrooms, in spite of a provocative nature which frequently places it on challenged book lists.
The recent film adaptation also continues to spread the story’s appeal. Yet, for all its charm, the story contains noticeable flaws.
The affecting nature of the novel is achieved via therapeutic letters that Charlie writes to an unnamed friend. He is afraid of starting high school. Plus, he is trying to deal with the recent suicide of his only friend as well as the death of his beloved aunt. The epistolary format feels like a stretch at times, especially when it comes to conveying long passages of dialogue. Even more jarring is Charlie’s voice. Journal and letter writing is very casual and intimate. Couple that with a teenager’s unpolished writing, and some readers will likely find the prose awkward.
Charlie is more than a little lost. His shy, introspective ways stem from various psychological issues which are revealed as the story progresses. By the end of the story, it does indeed seem like Charlie has experienced every element of teenage angst imaginable, such as trying LSD, aiding in an abortion, and feeling unrequited love. Conflicts abound, perhaps more than some deem believable, but the onslaught of issues really is true to many teens’ lives.
At times it may also feel like the characters are too one-dimensional: the clichéd gay friend, the well-intentioned English teacher, the racist grandfather. Yet, part of growing up is learning how to deal with the stereotypes all people try to apply to one another. Charlie’s therapist encourages him to participate, and he eventually comes to a better understanding of why people need something in their lives worth living for.
Despite his imperfection, Charlie’s endearing qualities creep into the reader’s heart. He always gets his acquaintances the perfect gift, he loves his mom very much, and he tries to be a good friend. Toward the end of the book, his love interest tells him, “’You can’t just sit there and put everybody’s lives ahead of yours and think that counts as love. You just can’t. You have to do things.’”
So how is it that a book with such obvious flaws can be touted as being practically perfect? It’s one of those rare instances where the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. Even when coincidence seems to solve too many conflicts in the book, the story leaves the reader feeling like they too have survived everything right along with Charlie. By the end of the book, both reader and narrator will experiences what it means to feel infinite.
You can connect with Stephen Chbosky via Goodreads.
What coming of age novels or movies have left the most lasting impressions upon you?
For more insight, read my Book Review Criteria.
Image Credit: Scared Guy by Frits Ahlefeldt. Please share responsibly. Jeri Walker, 2013
Wow… It sounds like one would almost relive their teenage years when reading this book. Not sure I want to go there. 🙂
Cheryl, I envy any writer who can capture all of the highs and lows of teenage angst. Charlie is a really lovable narrator.
My 14 year old has read this, I think at least twice now. This, like the Nicholas Sparks stuff that my girls read, is one I will probably never pick up. I would imagine your time in the classroom would have brought you in contact with quite a few wall flowers. Did you envision students of your past while reading this one?
You know the high school years were hard enough at the time. Living them all over again might not be that interesting to me… LOL
Glad you wrote about this because I probably wouldn’t have seen it otherwise! It’ll probably be a good read to get back in the state of mind of teenage years – but as others have mentioned, I’m not sure it’s worth the pain! 🙂
Again, another great post. I wouldn’t have thought about watching it let alone reading it, but after this review, I just might have to rent it.
It’s so true what you say,, “the whole is greater than the sum of its parts”. I’ve read several books and thought the same.
A modern classic!! ha! if this is what you call classic then God help the future of literature!!
Just teenage CRAP!! anybody can write that. wonder how it became a ‘bestseller’…was lured by this.
What is so special? every teenager goes through all this!
Balroop, that is your opinion and I am sure some would agree. I for one do not feel a book that gets at the depression that results from sexual abuse is teenage crap. Part of literature’s appeal is shedding light on shared experience, though we are all free to decide certain approaches may not appeal to our individual tastes.